[bombadil]

I think that the alchemy system is not really fair because a player that doesn't buy silks will not have dress, premium etc... and by the way he won't have same luck rates as others.
So its no as simple as to say "people are lucky or no"..

I also think the alchemy probability system is not always improved by the luck factor. As for example yesterday i succeeded two times making an item +4 without lucky (it takes me 5minutes); just after i try to up a weapon d13 : even with lucky : always fail at +2 at the beginning, then reached +5 but after 15 min ! Randomly...